debian-mirror-gitlab/doc/architecture/blueprints/runner_tokens/index.md

stage	group	comments	description
Verify	Runner	false	Next Runner Token Architecture

Next GitLab Runner Token Architecture

Summary

GitLab Runner is a core component of GitLab CI/CD that runs CI/CD jobs in a reliable and concurrent environment. Ever since the beginnings of the service as a Ruby program, runners are registered in a GitLab instance with a registration token - a randomly generated string of text. The registration token is unique for its given scope (instance, group, or project). The registration token proves that the party that registers the runner has administrative access to the instance, group, or project to which the runner is registered.

This approach has worked well in the initial years, but some major known issues started to become apparent as the target audience grew:

Problem	Symptoms
Single token per scope	- The registration token is shared by multiple runners: - Single tokens lower the value of auditing and make traceability almost impossible; - Copied in many places for self-registration of runners; - Reports of users storing tokens in unsecured locations; - Makes rotation of tokens costly. - In the case of a security event affecting the whole instance, rotating tokens requires users to update a table of projects/namespaces, which takes a significant amount of time.
No provision for automatic expiration	Requires manual intervention to change token. Addressed in #30942.
No permissions model	Used to register a runner for protected branches, and for any tags. In this case, the registration token has permission to do everything. Effectively, someone taking a possession of registration token could steal secrets or source code.
No traceability	Given that the token is not created by a user, and is accessible to all administrators, there is no possibility to know the source of a leaked token.
No historical records	When reset, the previous value of the registration token is not stored so there is no historical data to enable deeper auditing and inspection.
Token stored in project/namespace model	Inadvertent disclosure of token is possible.
Too many registered runners	It is too straightforward to register a new runner using a well-known registration token.

In light of these issues, it is important that we redesign the way in which we connect runners to the GitLab instance so that we can guarantee traceability, security, and performance.

We call this new mechanism the "next GitLab Runner Token architecture".

Proposal

The proposal addresses the issues of a single token per scope and token storage by eliminating the need for a registration token. Runner creation happens in the GitLab Runners settings page for the given scope, in the context of the logged-in user, which provides traceability. The page provides instructions to configure the newly-created runner in supported environments using the existing gitlab-runner register command.

The remaining concerns become non-issues due to the elimination of the registration token.

Using the authentication token in place of the registration token

In this proposal, runners created in the GitLab UI are assigned authentication tokens prefixed with glrt- (GitLab Runner Token).

The prefix allows the existing register command to use the authentication token in lieu of the current registration token (--registration-token), requiring minimal adjustments in existing workflows. The authentication token is shown to the user only once - after completing the creation flow - to discourage unintended reuse.

Given that the runner is pre-created through the GitLab UI, the register command fails if provided with arguments that are exposed in the runner creation form. Some examples are --tag-list, --run-untagged, --locked, or --access-level as these are sensitive parameters that should be decided at creation time by an administrator/owner. The runner configuration is generated through the existing register command, which can behave in two different ways depending on whether it is supplied a registration token or an authentication token in the --registration-token argument:

Token type	Behavior
Registration token	Leverages the POST /api/v4/runners REST endpoint to create a new runner, creating a new entry in config.toml.
Authentication token	Leverages the POST /api/v4/runners/verify REST endpoint to ensure the validity of the authentication token. Creates an entry in config.toml file and a system_id value in a sidecar file if missing (.runner_system_id).

Transition period

During a transition period, legacy tokens ("registration tokens") continue to be shown on the GitLab Runners settings page and to be accepted by the gitlab-runner register command. The legacy workflow is nevertheless discouraged in the UI. Users are steered towards the new flow consisting of creating the runner in the UI and using the resulting authentication token with the gitlab-runner register command as they do today. This approach reduces disruption to users responsible for deploying runners.

Reusing the runner authentication token across many machines

In the existing model, a new runner is created whenever a new worker is required. This has led to many situations where runners are left behind and become stale.

In the proposed model, a ci_runners table entry describes a configuration that the user can reuse across multiple machines. A unique system identifier is generated automatically whenever the runner application starts up or the configuration is saved. This allows differentiating the context in which the runner is being used.

The system_id value complements the short runner token that is currently used to identify a runner in command line output, CI job logs, and GitLab UI.

Given that the creation of runners involves user interaction, it should be possible to eventually lower the per-plan limit of CI runners that can be registered per scope.

Generating a system_id value

We ensure that a unique system identifier is assigned at all times to a gitlab-runner installation. The ID is derived from an existing machine identifier such as /etc/machine-id (on Linux) and hashed for privacy, in which case it is prefixed with s_. If an ID is not available, a random string is used instead, in which case it is prefixed with r_.

This unique ID identifies the gitlab-runner process and is sent on POST /api/v4/jobs requests for all runners in the config.toml file.

The ID is generated and saved both at gitlab-runner startup and whenever the configuration is saved to disk. Instead of saving the ID at the root of config.toml though, we save it to a new file that lives next to it - .runner_system_id. The goal for this new file is to make it less likely that IDs get reused due to manual copying of the config.toml file

s_cpwhDr7zFz4xBJujFeEM

Runner identification in CI jobs

For users to identify the machine where the job was executed, the unique identifier needs to be visible in CI job contexts. As a first iteration, GitLab Runner will include the unique system identifier in the build logs, wherever it publishes the short token SHA.

Given that the runner can potentially be reused with different unique system identifiers, we should store the unique system ID in the database. This ensures the unique system ID maps to a GitLab Runner's system_id value with the runner token. A new ci_runner_machines table holds information about each unique runner machine, with information regarding when the runner last connected, and what type of runner it was.

In the long term, the relevant fields are to be moved from the ci_runners into ci_runner_machines. Until the removal milestone though, they should be kept in the ci_runners as a fallback when a matching ci_runner_machines record does not exist. An expected scenario is the case when the table is created but the runner hasn't pinged the GitLab instance (for example if the runner is offline).

In addition, we should add the following columns to ci_runners:

• a user_id column to keep track of who created a runner;
• a registration_type enum column to ci_runners to signal whether a runner has been created using the legacy register method, or the new UI-based method. Possible values are :registration_token and :authenticated_user. This allows the stale runner cleanup service to determine which runners to clean up, and allows future uses that may not be apparent.

CREATE TABLE ci_runner (
  ...
  user_id bigint
  registration_type int8
)

The ci_builds_runner_session (or ci_builds or ci_builds_metadata) shall reference ci_runner_machines. We might consider a more efficient way to store contacted_at than updating the existing record.

CREATE TABLE ci_builds_runner_session (
    ...
    runner_machine_id bigint NOT NULL
);

CREATE TABLE ci_runner_machines (
    id integer NOT NULL,
    machine_id character varying UNIQUE NOT NULL,
    contacted_at timestamp without time zone,
    version character varying,
    revision character varying,
    platform character varying,
    architecture character varying,
    ip_address character varying,
    executor_type smallint,
);

Advantages

• Easier for users to wrap their minds around the concept: instead of two types of tokens, there is a single type of token - the per-runner authentication token. Having two types of tokens frequently results in misunderstandings when discussing issues;
• Runners can always be traced back to the user who created it, using the audit log;
• The claims of a CI runner are known at creation time, and cannot be changed from the runner (for example, changing the access_level/protected flag). Authenticated users may however still edit these settings through the GitLab UI;
• Easier cleanup of stale runners, which doesn't touch the ci_runner table.

Details

In the proposed approach, we create a distinct way to configure runners that is usable alongside the current registration token method during a transition period. The idea is to avoid having the Runner make API calls that allow it to leverage a single "god-like" token to register new runners.

The new workflow looks as follows:

1. The user opens the Runners settings page (instance, group, or project level);

2. The user fills in the details regarding the new desired runner, namely description, tags, protected, locked, etc.;

3. The user clicks Create. That results in the following:

   1. Creates a new runner in the ci_runners table (and corresponding glrt- prefixed authentication token);
   2. Presents the user with instructions on how to configure this new runner on a machine, with possibilities for different supported deployment scenarios (e.g. shell, docker-compose, Helm chart, etc.) This information contains a token which is available to the user only once, and the UI makes it clear to the user that the value shall not be shown again, as registering the same runner multiple times is discouraged (though not impossible).

4. The user copies and pastes the instructions for the intended deployment scenario (a register command), leading to the following actions:

   1. Upon executing the new gitlab-runner register command in the instructions, gitlab-runner performs a call to the POST /api/v4/runners/verify with the given runner token;
   2. If the POST /api/v4/runners/verify GitLab endpoint validates the token, the config.toml file is populated with the configuration;
   3. Whenever a runner pings for a job, the respective ci_runner_machines record is "upserted" with the latest information about the runner (with Redis cache in front of it like we do for Runner heartbeats).

As part of the transition period, we provide admins and top-level group owners with an instance/group-level setting (allow_runner_registration_token) to disable the legacy registration token functionality and enforce using only the new workflow. Any attempt by a gitlab-runner register command to hit the POST /api/v4/runners endpoint to register a new runner with a registration token results in a HTTP 410 Gone status code.

The instance setting is inherited by the groups. This means that if the legacy registration method is disabled at the instance method, the descendant groups/projects mandatorily prevents the legacy registration method.

The registration token workflow is to be deprecated (with a deprecation notice printed by the gitlab-runner register command) and removed at a future major release after the concept is proven stable and customers have migrated to the new workflow.

Handling of legacy runners

Legacy versions of GitLab Runner do not send the unique system identifier in its requests, and we will not change logic in Workhorse to handle unique system IDs. This can be improved upon in the future after the legacy registration system is removed, and runners have been upgraded to newer versions.

Job pings from such legacy runners results in a ci_runner_machines record containing a <legacy> machine_id field value.

Not using the unique system ID means that all connected runners with the same token are notified, instead of just the runner matching the exact system identifier. While not ideal, this is not an issue per-se.

ci_runner_machines record lifetime

New records are created when the runner pings the GitLab instance for new jobs, if a record matching the token+system_id does not already exist.

Due to the time-decaying nature of the ci_runner_machines records, they are automatically cleaned after 7 days after the last contact from the respective runner.

Required adaptations

Migration to ci_runner_machines table

When details from ci_runner_machines are needed, we need to fall back to the existing fields in ci_runner if a match is not found in ci_runner_machines.

REST API

API endpoints receiving runner tokens should be changed to also take an optional system_id parameter, sent alongside with the runner token (most often as a JSON parameter on the request body).

GraphQL CiRunner type

The CiRunner type closely reflects the ci_runners model. This means that machine information such as ipAddress, architectureName, and executorName among others are no longer singular values in the proposed approach. We can live with that fact for the time being and start returning lists of unique values, separated by commas. The respective CiRunner fields must return the values for the ci_runner_machines entries (falling back to ci_runner record if non-existent).

Stale runner cleanup

The functionality to clean up stale runners needs to be adapted to clean up ci_runner_machines records instead of ci_runners records.

At some point after the removal of the registration token support, we'll want to create a background migration to clean up stale runners that have been created with a registration token (leveraging the enum column created in the ci_runners table.

Runner creation through API

Automated runner creation may be allowed, although always through authenticated API calls - using PAT tokens for example - such that every runner is associated with an owner.

Implementation plan

Stage 1 - Deprecations

Component	Milestone	Changes
GitLab Rails app	15.6	Deprecate POST /api/v4/runners endpoint for 17.0. This hinges on a proposal to allow deprecating REST API endpoints for security reasons.
GitLab Runner	15.6	Add deprecation notice for register command for 17.0.
GitLab Runner Helm Chart	15.6	Add deprecation notice for runnerRegistrationToken command for 17.0.
GitLab Runner Operator	15.6	Add deprecation notice for runner-registration-token command for 17.0.
GitLab Runner / GitLab Rails app	15.7	Add deprecation notice for registration token reset for 17.0.

Stage 2 - Prepare gitlab-runner for system_id

Component	Milestone	Changes
GitLab Runner	15.x	Ensure a sidecar TOML file exists with a system_id value. Log new system ID values with INFO level as they get assigned.
GitLab Runner	15.x	Log unique system ID in the build logs.
GitLab Runner	15.x	Label Prometheus metrics with unique system ID.
GitLab Runner	15.x	Prepare register command to fail if runner server-side configuration options are passed together with a new glrt- token.

Stage 3 - Database changes

Component	Milestone	Changes
GitLab Rails app		Create database migration to add columns to ci_runners table.
GitLab Rails app		Create database migration to add ci_runner_machines table.
GitLab Rails app		Create database migration to add ci_runner_machines.machine_id foreign key to ci_builds_runner_session table.
GitLab Rails app		Create database migrations to add allow_runner_registration_token setting to application_settings and namespace_settings tables (default: true).
GitLab Runner		Use runner token + system_id JSON parameters in POST /jobs/request request in the heartbeat request to update the ci_runner_machines cache/table.
GitLab Runner		Start sending system_id value in POST /jobs/request request and other follow-up requests that require identifying the unique system.
GitLab Rails app		Create service similar to StaleGroupRunnersPruneCronWorker service to clean up ci_runner_machines records instead of ci_runners records. Existing service continues to exist but focuses only on legacy runners.

Stage 4 - New UI

Component	Milestone	Changes
GitLab Runner		Implement new GraphQL user-authenticated API to create a new runner.
GitLab Runner		Add prefix to newly generated runner authentication tokens.
GitLab Rails app		Implement UI to create new runner.
GitLab Rails app		GraphQL changes to CiRunner type.
GitLab Rails app		UI changes to runner details view (listing of platform, architecture, IP address, etc.) (?)

Stage 5 - Optional disabling of registration token

Component	Milestone	Changes
GitLab Rails app		Add UI to allow disabling use of registration tokens at project or group level.
GitLab Rails app	16.0	Introduce :disable_runner_registration_tokens feature flag (enabled by default) to control whether use of registration tokens is allowed.
GitLab Rails app		Make POST /api/v4/runners endpoint permanently return HTTP 410 Gone if either allow_runner_registration_token setting or :disable_runner_registration_tokens feature flag disables registration tokens. A future v5 version of the API should return HTTP 404 Not Found.
GitLab Rails app		Start refusing job requests that don't include a unique ID, if either allow_runner_registration_token setting or :disable_runner_registration_tokens feature flag disables registration tokens.
GitLab Rails app		Hide legacy UI showing registration with a registration token, if :disable_runner_registration_tokens feature flag disables registration tokens.

Stage 6 - Removals

Component	Milestone	Changes
GitLab Rails app	17.0	Remove legacy UI showing registration with a registration token.
GitLab Runner	17.0	Remove runner model arguments from register command (for example --run-untagged, --tag-list, etc.)
GitLab Rails app	17.0	Create database migrations to drop allow_runner_registration_token setting columns from application_settings and namespace_settings tables.
GitLab Rails app	17.0	Create database migrations to drop: - runners_registration_token/runners_registration_token_encrypted columns from application_settings; - runners_token/runners_token_encrypted from namespaces table; - runners_token/runners_token_encrypted from projects table.
GitLab Rails app	17.0	Remove :disable_runner_registration_tokens feature flag.

Status

Status: RFC.

Who

Proposal:

Role	Who
Authors	Kamil Trzciński, Tomasz Maczukin, Pedro Pombeiro
Architecture Evolution Coach	Kamil Trzciński
Engineering Leader	Elliot Rushton, Cheryl Li
Product Manager	Darren Eastman, Jackie Porter
Domain Expert / Runner	Tomasz Maczukin

DRIs:

Role	Who
Leadership	Elliot Rushton
Product	Darren Eastman
Engineering	Tomasz Maczukin, Pedro Pombeiro

Domain experts:

Area	Who
Domain Expert / Runner	Tomasz Maczukin